Despite the widespread cynicism Evan Stamatiou has found COP 31 to be optimistic for serious shifts in policies but Australia’s political role in approving coal mines.
COP cynicism seems to be at an all-time high these days. Red hot inflation is burning holes in wallets everywhere means most folk don’t have the headspace to worry about a roasting planet. Then there’s the deplorably large percentage of people who still don’t think that climate change is a thing thanks to the long tentacles of the fossil fuel lobby, and a sustained brainwashing campaign that’s as militant as it is subtle.
Strangely aligned with the above groups are vocal critics from within the climate movement. They argue that spewing greenhouse emissions from thousands of airplanes just so that humans can stream hot air from their mouths is clearly detrimental to our plight.
With the above perspectives in mind, much of my time here in Antalya has been plagued by thoughts of how humanity could do this conference better. Yet for all the holes that we could poke at COP31 I have a clear impression that this year’s gathering will significantly accelerate global decarbonisation efforts.
That might sound strange to many given the barrage of headlines focusing on the snail’s pace progress of negotiations and awkward hot mic moments. But these news items have almost universally missed a large chunk of the COP31 story, and for the benefit of those who are unfamiliar with how COPs work, it’s probably worth peeling the onion a little.
For those countries with a real narrative on climate action, panel discussions are electrifying and catapult the audience several months ahead of the debate on all sorts of hot-button climate issues like electrification, green steel, low carbon cement, the emerging African critical minerals economy, and data centres just to name a few
Sitting opposite the plenary halls – where negotiators argue over where to place commas and semicolons in intricate decision texts – is the “Blue Zone”. Think of the Blue Zone as a mega climate expo, the largest gathering of climate experts in the world. The Blue Zone is a pavilion city, with countries and a smattering of NGOs and civil society groups all setting up shop under one giant roof.
Although the Blue Zone is physically disconnected from the negotiations it’s still intricately linked. Here countries showcase their latest ambition, technologies, and ideas to delegates from around the globe through expert panel sessions, fireside discussions, networking drinks and signing ceremonies.
Not all countries put the same effort into their pavilions. Countries with little climate ambition prefer to fill them with free pens, posters of birds, and images of sweet old people wearing peculiar costumes. But for those countries with a real narrative on climate action, panel discussions are electrifying and catapult the audience several months ahead of the debate on all sorts of hot button climate issues like electrification, green steel, low carbon cement, the emerging African critical minerals economy, and data centres just to name a few.
The Portuguese pavilion has been a standout not just for the calibre of its panel sessions and occasional custard tarts, but also for the tapestry loom that its delegation chose to set up at the pavilion entrance to entice foreign delegates into their sessions. Whether it was intentional or not the tapestry loom is a perfect metaphor for the entire COP itself.
COP31 has brought thousands of the best climate minds from across to globe together. Each delegate has come to this conference clutching their own threads, looking to weave their technology, product, model, or idea into the rich global tapestry of global climate action. The interweaving happens in real time and for two short weeks here the tapestry has extended forward at warp speed.
Blue Zone developments often come back to influence negotiations themselves. Just one example was this year’s Blue Zone launch of the African Non-State Actors Working Group on Critical Minerals. The Working Group has a shared purpose to advance accountable, people centred and nature positive critical mineral development in Africa. Importantly, it’s aimed at helping African countries take control of their critical minerals economy rather than having terms of engagement dictated to them by Western players and China who prefer to follow the traditional colonial playbook. This initiative will help Africa build geopolitical leverage so that it can wedge developed countries on the thorny issue of climate finance in future COP negotiations.
The success of the Blue Zone this year will no doubt super-charge climate experts with new ideas that they can share with their respective governments when they settle back home. This aspect of COP gives me real hope, because often it’s for want of a clear vision of technology driven and economically viable transition pathways that some countries play obstructionist roles in the negotiations process.
Of course, there are other reasons why countries obstruct negotiations with much commentary around how net exporters of fossil fuel block discussions on fossil fuel phase-out.
Australia, as president of negotiations this year, has championed the “35 by 35” electrification pledge to ramp up electricity’s share of global final energy consumption to 35 per cent by 2035. To the surprise of many, Climate Change and Energy Minister Chris Bowen has also come out this week with a bold cover text calling for, amongst many things, countries to accelerate fossil fuel phase out. Regardless of how the text evolves through negotiations it sets a clear statement on Australian climate leadership.
Obviously, this leadership statement jars with Australia’s continued approval of new coal and gas projects. But in the current political context it makes perfect sense for the government not to announce any significant reversal of course because to so would simply stoke the mother of all climate wars and put Pauline Hanson in the Lodge.
Perhaps the smartest tactic would be strategic ambiguity on this issue coupled with a significant ramp up of government led engagement with regional partners to help accelerate their transitions away from fossil fuels. Add to this an Australian carbon border adjustment mechanism (CBAM) and we would send a concrete signal to Asian markets on the need to decarbonise but that we’re also here to help them on that journey.
Negotiations have been re-energised by Bowen’s proposed cover text but it’s too early to know where things will land. Regardless, this has been an implementation COP, with the coordination of climate action in the Blue Zone and the concerted efforts of our negotiators being real causes for optimism.
Antalya is perhaps most famous for its dramatic mountain ranges, but for two full weeks these have been mostly obscured by the piles of overripe bananas that conference organisers have lovingly pushed onto reluctant delegates. Let’s hope everyone makes it home healthy so that they can keep weaving forward the climate action tapestry before the silly season is upon us.
