The proposed data centre site sits in the headwaters of the Warragamba drinking water catchment

LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Derryn Heilbuth’s opinion piece An Australian first: Southern Highlands community sets new terms for data centre development“, presents a curated, consultancy-run workshop as though it were the democratic voice of the Southern Highlands. As a Southern Highlands resident, I must correct the record on what the article omits and why the model it promotes poses a serious risk to statutory planning integrity.

First, 158 self-selected online participants and a cohort of 38 individuals do not speak for a shire of more than 52,000 residents, nor do they override formal statutory objections lodged by locals who oppose segmented DAs aimed at hyperscale data centre industrialisation outright.

Second, the op-Ed omits the single most critical fact governing the live proposal at 30–40 Douglas Road, Moss Vale (SSD-102795459): the site sits in the headwaters of the Warragamba drinking water catchment, supplying potable water to more than five million residents across Greater Sydney and the Southern Highlands.

Worse still, the proposal pairs 21 data centre halls with nearly 700 megawatts of continuous behind-the-meter fossil gas generation and water-intensive cooling in an inland valley prone to nocturnal temperature inversions.

Citing a grid-connected solar farm at Walla Walla or a municipal agreement in Pennsylvania does nothing to alter the hydrological and airshed reality facing Moss Vale, in the Southern Highlands.

Third, under Section 4.15 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) and settled planning law, site suitability is a threshold legal test: an unsuitable industrial facility cannot be brought into acceptability with a “community investment fund.” Yet by starting from the false premise that data centre expansion is a “settled question,” this non-statutory pilot bypasses whether a project belongs in a drinking water catchment at all and jumps straight to negotiating benefit-sharing terms.

Finally, readers deserve transparency regarding the commercial architecture behind this “Australian first.”

The author is the executive chair of BWD Strategic, one of the consortium partners pitching this framework for inclusion in 2027 national standards, yet describes BWD’s role in terms of an “independent” assessment.

Moreover, because the pilot’s headline $1 million per megawatt fund materialises only if a data centre is approved, any entity positioned to hold, manage, or draw advisory fees from that pool acquires a built-in financial stake in approvals proceeding.

Genuine community consultation respects a community’s statutory right to say “no”,it does not package a town into a consulting blueprint to negotiate the price of its own compromise, where only the consultants benefit.

Sincerely,
Ingrid Skirka
Southern Highlands resident

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *